Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy
1. General Provisions
The scientific journal Environment & Health supports the responsible use of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies in scientific research, manuscript preparation, and editorial activities, provided that the principles of research integrity, transparency, reliability of findings, and confidentiality are upheld.
The journal recognizes the potential of AI tools as supplementary resources for research, data analysis, language editing, and the preparation of scholarly materials. However, the use of such technologies does not replace researchers' intellectual contributions, independent scientific evaluation, or human responsibility for the content and outcomes of scholarly work.
This policy applies to authors, reviewers, editors, and all other participants in the editorial and publication process.
The policy takes into account the international recommendations and guidance of:
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) – guidance on the use of artificial intelligence in scholarly publishing.
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) – principles of publication ethics and responsible authorship.
- World Association of Medical Editors (WAME) – recommendations concerning generative AI in scholarly publications.
- European Association of Science Editors (EASE) – recommendations on the use of AI in scholarly communication.
2. Authorship and Authors' Responsibilities
Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of scholarly articles.
Authorship requires an intellectual contribution, approval of the final manuscript, and accountability for the accuracy and integrity of the research, in accordance with the ICMJE authorship criteria.
Regardless of whether AI tools have been used, authors retain full responsibility for:
- The originality of the scholarly work.
- The reliability and accuracy of the data presented.
- The scientific justification of the research methods.
- The accuracy and appropriateness of statistical analyses.
- The scientific reasoning and conclusions.
- The accuracy and authenticity of bibliographic references.
- Compliance with copyright requirements and research ethics.
All AI-assisted outputs must be critically evaluated and verified by the authors.
The use of AI tools does not exempt authors from responsibility for errors, inaccuracies, biased outputs, or unreliable statements.
3. Permitted Uses of AI by Authors
Authors may use artificial intelligence tools for supplementary purposes, provided that appropriate human oversight, verification of outputs, and disclosure are ensured in accordance with this policy.
Permitted uses include:
Language Editing and Translation
Improving grammar, academic writing style, terminology, sentence structure, and translation, provided that the scientific content, research findings, and authors' conclusions remain unchanged.
Technical Manuscript Preparation
Assisting with the formatting of text, tables, reference lists, and other manuscript components, subject to mandatory verification of the resulting output.
Literature Searching and Organization
Assisting with literature searches, preliminary organization, and analysis of scientific information.
All bibliographic sources, DOIs, citations, and scientific claims must be verified by the authors against the original sources.
Data Analysis and Programming
Assisting with data processing, code development, statistical calculations, modelling, or visualization of results, provided that the validity of the methods, calculations, and outputs is independently verified.
Preparation of Illustrative Materials
Creating supplementary diagrams, infographics, and other illustrations, provided that AI use is clearly disclosed and scientific data are not misrepresented.
Where AI is used as a direct method of scientific investigation, its application must be appropriately described in the Materials and Methods section, including the AI tool used, its functions, and the procedures applied to verify the reliability of the results.
4. Prohibited Uses of AI
The journal prohibits:
- Generating scientific text, research findings, or conclusions without substantial intellectual contributions from the authors and appropriate verification.
- Creating fabricated experimental, clinical, epidemiological, or statistical data and presenting them as findings from actual research.
- Fabricating, falsifying, or manipulating scientific research findings.
- Generating fictitious bibliographic references, DOIs, citations, or source links.
- Presenting unverified AI-generated statements as reliable scientific evidence.
- Inappropriately altering scientific images, graphs, measurement results, or other original research materials.
- Concealing the use of AI where disclosure is required.
- Infringing copyright, breaching confidentiality, or violating personal data protection requirements.
Generative AI must not replace the independent conduct of research, critical appraisal of scientific evidence, or the formulation of scientifically justified conclusions by the authors.
5. Disclosure of AI Use by Authors
The editorial office requires transparent disclosure of the use of generative artificial intelligence during manuscript preparation or the conduct of research.
Each scholarly article must include a separate section immediately before the reference list entitled:
DECLARATION ON THE USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (AI)
Where generative AI has been used, authors must specify:
- The name of the AI tool and, where possible, its version or model.
- The purpose and nature of its use.
- The stages of manuscript preparation or research at which AI was employed.
- Confirmation that the outputs were verified and that the authors accept responsibility for the work.
Where AI has been used for data analysis, programming, modelling, or other research activities, the relevant methods must also be described in the Materials and Methods section in sufficient detail to enable their evaluation and reproducibility.
The use of conventional spelling, punctuation, or automated formatting tools that do not generate new content does not require separate disclosure.
Examples of AI Use Declarations
Where generative AI was not used:
"Generative artificial intelligence was not used during the conduct of the research or the preparation of this manuscript."
Where generative AI was used for language editing:
"During manuscript preparation, [name of AI tool, model/version] was used for language and stylistic editing. The scientific content, research findings, and conclusions were reviewed and approved by the authors. The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the publication."
Where generative AI was used to assist with data analysis:
"During data analysis, [name of AI tool, model/version] was used for [specific purpose]. The methodology of its use is described in the Materials and Methods section. The resulting outputs were verified by the authors."
These statements must be adapted to accurately reflect the actual use of AI tools.
6. Confidentiality and Protection of Research Data
Authors, reviewers, and editors must ensure the protection of confidential information when using artificial intelligence tools.
The following information must not be submitted to external AI services without an appropriate legal basis, the necessary permissions, and adequate safeguards for information protection:
- Personal or medical data of research participants.
- Unpublished confidential findings belonging to other researchers.
- Materials subject to access restrictions under research agreements or contracts.
- Information protected by copyright or professional confidentiality obligations.
The use of AI to process research data must comply with applicable legislation, research ethics requirements, and personal data protection regulations.
7. Use of AI by Reviewers
Reviewers are personally responsible for the independence, objectivity, and scientific validity of their peer review reports.
Manuscripts submitted for peer review are confidential materials.
Reviewers must not upload full manuscripts, manuscript excerpts, unpublished data, tables, figures, or other confidential materials to external generative AI systems unless appropriate confidentiality safeguards can be ensured and all necessary permissions have been obtained.
Reviewers are also prohibited from:
- Delegating independent scientific evaluation of manuscripts to AI systems.
- Using unverified AI-generated conclusions as the basis for publication recommendations.
- Generating peer review reports without conducting their own critical assessment.
- Using authors' unpublished materials for personal or professional advantage.
The use of supplementary tools for language editing of reviewers' own reports is permitted, provided that no confidential materials are disclosed to such tools and the journal's editorial policies are observed.
Any other use of generative AI during peer review requires prior approval from the editorial office and disclosure of the nature of its use. Manuscript materials may be submitted to AI systems only where adequate confidentiality safeguards and the necessary permissions are in place.
Scientific peer review must be conducted by a human reviewer with appropriate subject-specific expertise.
Further information: Peer Review Process.
8. Use of AI by Editors and Editorial Staff
Editors and editorial staff may use automated tools for supplementary organizational and technical tasks, provided that confidentiality is maintained and appropriate human oversight is exercised.
Such tools may include text similarity detection software, manuscript formatting tools, bibliographic error detection systems, and metadata completeness checks.
Where AI tools are used for these purposes, the editorial office must consider their technical limitations, the possibility of inaccurate outputs, and the risks associated with disclosing confidential information.
Unpublished manuscripts, peer review reports, editorial correspondence, or personal data must not be uploaded to external generative AI services without adequate confidentiality safeguards and the necessary permissions.
Decisions concerning manuscript alignment with the journal's scope, referral for peer review, acceptance, revision, or rejection must be made by authorized editors.
Artificial intelligence must not independently make final editorial decisions.
The editorial office does not regard automated AI-detection results as the sole evidence of a violation of research integrity.
Where the journal introduces AI systems to analyze manuscript content, identify potential violations, or support editorial decision-making, information about the nature of such use must be made available to authors.
The use of AI in editorial activities must not compromise the independence, impartiality, or confidentiality of scientific peer review.
9. Monitoring Compliance and Responding to Violations
The editorial office reserves the right to assess compliance with this policy during initial editorial screening, peer review, and after article publication.
Where justified concerns arise regarding the use of AI, the editorial office may request:
- Explanations from authors or other participants in the publication process.
- Information about the AI tools used and the nature of their application.
- Relevant research materials, original data, or details of analytical methods.
- A revised or clarified AI use declaration.
Decisions regarding potential violations are made following an assessment of the specific circumstances, explanations provided, and available evidence.
The results of automated AI-generated text detection are not, in themselves, sufficient grounds for rejecting or retracting a scholarly article.
Depending on the nature of the violation, the editorial office may require corrections to the manuscript or disclosure statement, reject the manuscript, or initiate post-publication measures in accordance with the journal's policies.
Where a violation affects the reliability of an already published article, the journal may apply procedures for Correction, Expression of Concern, or Retraction.
Complaints and appeals concerning the application of this policy are handled in accordance with the journal's procedure for handling complaints concerning research integrity and publication ethics.
10. Final Provisions
The editorial office of Environment & Health supports the development and responsible application of modern artificial intelligence technologies, provided that scientific reliability, transparency, and accountability of all participants in the publication process are ensured.
AI may be used only as a supplementary tool and must not replace authors' intellectual contributions, independent peer review, or scientifically justified editorial decisions.
This policy is periodically reviewed and updated to reflect technological developments and international recommendations on scholarly publishing.
International Guidelines and Recommendations

