Handling Complaints Concerning Research Integrity and Publication Ethics

1. General Provisions

The scientific journal Environment & Health ensures the objective, impartial, and confidential handling of reports concerning potential violations of research integrity, publication ethics, and established editorial procedures.

The editorial office considers substantiated complaints relating to submitted manuscripts, published articles, and the conduct of authors, reviewers, editors, and other participants in the publication process.

Complaints are handled in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics and Editorial Policy, the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), and internationally recognized standards of responsible scholarly publishing.

The submission of a complaint does not, in itself, constitute evidence of misconduct. All allegations are assessed in accordance with the principles of presumption of good faith, objectivity, proportionality, and the right of the parties concerned to provide explanations.

2. Grounds for Submitting a Complaint

The editorial office considers reports of potential violations, including:

  • Plagiarism or the unauthorized use of others' texts, data, ideas, or images.
  • Fabrication, falsification, or inappropriate manipulation of research data.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication without appropriate disclosure.
  • Violations of authorship principles, including guest, gift, or ghost authorship.
  • Violations of research ethics requirements, informed consent procedures, or personal data protection.
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest that may substantially affect the reliability of research findings or the independence of manuscript evaluation.
  • Manipulation of the peer review process, breaches of confidentiality, or reviewer bias.
  • Violations of editorial independence, inappropriate editorial conduct, or failure to comply with established editorial procedures.
  • Copyright infringement, citation manipulation, the use of unreliable sources, and other significant violations of publication ethics.

Previous posting of a manuscript on a preprint server does not, in itself, constitute grounds for a complaint concerning duplicate publication, provided that the journal's Preprint Policy has been followed.

Scientific debate, evidence-based criticism of research findings, or disagreement with authors' conclusions do not, in themselves, constitute violations of publication ethics.

3. Who May Submit a Complaint

Complaints may be submitted by authors, readers, reviewers, editors, representatives of research institutions or organizations, or other individuals who possess substantiated information concerning a potential violation.

The editorial office may also initiate an investigation on its own initiative where relevant circumstances are identified during editorial assessment, peer review, or after publication.

Anonymous reports may be considered if they contain sufficiently specific and verifiable information. The absence of the complainant's contact details may limit the editorial office's ability to request clarification or communicate the outcome of the investigation.

4. Procedure for Submitting a Complaint

Complaints must be submitted in writing to the journal's editorial office by email or postal correspondence.

Editorial Office Email: environ.and.health@health.gov.ua

Postal Address: Editorial Office of «Довкілля та здоров’я» (Environment & Health), State Institution “Marzieiev Institute for Public Health of the National Academy of Medical Sciences of Ukraine”, 50 Hetmana Pavla Polubotka Street, Kyiv, 02094, Ukraine.

Complainants are encouraged to provide:

  1. Their name and contact details, unless the complaint is submitted anonymously.
  2. The article title, DOI, manuscript identification number, or other information sufficient to identify the material concerned.
  3. A description of the alleged violation, including specific relevant circumstances.
  4. Documents, references, or other available evidence supporting the allegations.

Complainants must refrain from knowingly submitting false information or unlawfully disclosing personal or confidential data.

The editorial office may request additional explanations or materials necessary for an objective assessment of the complaint.

5. Registration and Preliminary Assessment of Complaints

The editorial office acknowledges receipt of a complaint within five working days, provided that the complainant has supplied contact information.

Each complaint is recorded in the journal's internal complaints register, including the date of receipt, subject of the complaint, person responsible for handling it, and current status of the investigation.

During the preliminary assessment, the editorial office determines:

  • Whether the matter falls within the journal's responsibilities and authority.
  • Whether the complaint contains sufficiently specific information to enable verification.
  • Whether it concerns a submitted manuscript, a published article, or editorial procedures.
  • Whether any conflicts of interest exist among those responsible for handling the complaint.

Following the preliminary assessment, the editorial office may decide to initiate an investigation, request additional information, refer the matter to an appropriate authorized person, or close the complaint with a reasoned explanation where insufficient grounds exist for further investigation.

6. Investigation of Alleged Violations

The Editor-in-Chief or another authorized editor who has no conflict of interest appoints a responsible individual or establishes a group to investigate the complaint.

During the investigation, the editorial office may:

  • Examine the manuscript, published article, peer review reports, bibliographic references, and supporting evidence.
  • Use text similarity detection software and other analytical tools.
  • Request written explanations from authors, reviewers, and other individuals concerned.
  • Consult independent scientific or methodological experts.
  • Contact the research institution where the study was conducted to investigate matters requiring access to original research data or internal documentation.

Individuals against whom substantiated allegations have been made must be given an opportunity to respond before a decision is reached, provided that doing so does not conflict with applicable legal requirements concerning information protection or compromise the proper conduct of the investigation.

Automated text similarity results do not, in themselves, constitute evidence of plagiarism and must be evaluated in context, taking into account appropriate citation practices.

Where potential research misconduct requires the establishment of facts relating to the conduct of a study, the editorial office cooperates with the relevant research institutions and other competent authorities within their respective areas of responsibility.

The editorial office is responsible for the integrity of the scholarly record and its own publication decisions but does not replace disciplinary proceedings or other formal procedures conducted by research institutions.

7. Conflicts of Interest and Independence of the Investigation

Individuals who have personal, professional, financial, or other conflicts of interest relating to the subject of a complaint must not participate in its investigation or in the decision-making process.

Complaints concerning the conduct of a particular editor must not be investigated or decided by that editor.

If a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, responsibility for handling it is transferred to another independent, authorized individual. Where necessary, the publishing institution arranges an independent investigation involving experts who have no conflicts of interest.

Administrative assistance in handling a complaint does not give the institution's administration the authority to interfere with routine scientific and editorial decisions concerning manuscript publication.

Manuscripts submitted by members of the Editorial Board, Editorial Council, Editorial Staff, or employees of the publishing institution are assessed under the standard procedures, without preferential treatment or simplified review requirements.

8. Decisions Following Complaint Investigation

Depending on the findings of the investigation, the editorial office may reach one of the following decisions:

1. Complaint Not Substantiated

Insufficient grounds have been established to determine that a violation occurred or to justify editorial action.

2. Complaint Fully or Partially Substantiated

Circumstances requiring an editorial response have been established.

3. Further Investigation Required

The available information is insufficient to reach a final decision. Additional materials or findings from a competent institution may be requested.

4. Matter Outside the Editorial Office's Remit

Where possible, the complainant is informed of the authority or institution to which the matter may appropriately be referred.

Where a violation is confirmed, the editorial office may take appropriate action depending on the nature and seriousness of the circumstances identified, including:

  • Requiring corrections to the manuscript or additional disclosures.
  • Rejecting a manuscript under consideration.
  • Arranging a new round of independent peer review.
  • Publishing a Correction.
  • Publishing an Expression of Concern.
  • Issuing a Retraction of a published article.
  • Notifying the relevant research institution or another competent authority where sufficient grounds exist.

The selection of an appropriate measure takes into account the established facts, nature of the violation, reliability of the research findings, and relevant COPE recommendations.

The purpose of correcting or retracting a publication is to safeguard the integrity of the scholarly record, rather than to punish authors.

Decisions concerning corrections or retractions are implemented in accordance with the journal's Retraction Policy.

9. Notification of Outcomes and Investigation Timelines

The editorial office informs the complainant in writing of the outcome of the investigation, to the extent that such information may be disclosed without compromising confidentiality or the rights of other individuals.

The duration of the investigation depends on the nature of the complaint, the extent of the evidence required, and the need to consult independent experts or research institutions.

The editorial office aims to complete investigations within a reasonable timeframe and informs complainants of significant delays.

Where additional time is required, the editorial office notifies the complainant that the investigation is being extended, provided that contact details are available.

Public notification of the outcome is provided where necessary to correct or clarify the scholarly record, including through the publication of a Correction, Expression of Concern, or Retraction notice.

Not every substantiated complaint requires a separate public statement. Information concerning internal editorial measures may remain confidential where those measures do not affect the reliability of the published scientific record.

10. Appeals and Reconsideration

Individuals who disagree with the outcome of a complaint investigation or an editorial decision may submit a reasoned appeal.

An appeal must be submitted within 30 calendar days of receipt of the relevant decision.

The appeal must specify the grounds for reconsideration, including potential procedural violations, conflicts of interest, significant errors, or new circumstances that were not considered during the initial assessment.

Reconsideration is undertaken by an authorized individual who has no conflict of interest and, wherever organizationally feasible, was not involved in making the decision under appeal.

Independent experts may be consulted where necessary.

The editorial office informs the appellant of the outcome within 30 calendar days of receiving the appeal or provides notification of a justified extension of the review period.

Submitting an appeal does not guarantee that the previous decision will be overturned.

The procedure for appeals against decisions to accept or reject manuscripts is also specified in the journal's Peer Review Process.

11. Confidentiality and Protection of Complainants

The editorial office maintains the confidentiality of investigation materials and the personal data of complainants and other participants in accordance with applicable legislation.

The complainant's identity is not disclosed without an appropriate legal basis. Where it is necessary to share information with other individuals or institutions for investigative purposes, disclosure is limited to what is reasonably necessary.

The editorial office does not tolerate discrimination or biased treatment of individuals who report potential violations in good faith.

Submitting a complaint in good faith must not, in itself, constitute grounds for refusing to consider the complainant's other manuscripts or adversely influencing the outcomes of their peer review.

Confidentiality is maintained within the editorial office's capabilities and applicable legal requirements; absolute anonymity of the complainant cannot be guaranteed in all circumstances.

12. Record Retention

Complaints, supporting materials, editorial correspondence, expert reports, and decisions are retained by the editorial office in accordance with its internal recordkeeping procedures and personal data protection requirements.

Records relating to complaint investigations are retained for five years after the investigation has been concluded, unless applicable legislation or the circumstances of a particular case require a different retention period.

Access to these materials is restricted to authorized individuals within the scope of their official responsibilities.

13. Final Provisions

The editorial office of «Довкілля та здоров’я» (Environment & Health) considers reports of potential violations of research integrity and publication ethics regardless of whether they are received before or after publication of the manuscript concerned.

Complaints are handled in accordance with the journal's approved editorial procedures and the principles of impartiality, confidentiality, and responsibility for maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.

This policy is periodically reviewed and updated to reflect international recommendations and developments in scholarly publishing practice.

 

International Guidelines and Recommendations

  1. COPE – Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.
  2. COPE – General Approach to Publication Ethics for the Editorial Office.
  3. COPE – Retraction Guidelines (редакція 2025 року).
  4. ICMJE – Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals.