Peer Review Process
1. General Provisions
The scientific journal Environment & Health ensures independent, objective, and confidential peer review of scientific manuscripts in accordance with international standards of scholarly publishing and the principles of publication ethics.
Peer review aims to assess the scientific novelty, relevance, methodological rigor, reliability of findings, validity of conclusions, and alignment of submitted manuscripts with the journal's aims and scope.
The journal employs a double-blind peer review process, in which the identities of authors are concealed from reviewers and the identities of reviewers are concealed from authors.
The manuscript evaluation process includes initial editorial screening, independent external peer review, manuscript revision where necessary, and a final editorial decision.
Editorial procedures are guided by the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), and internationally recognized principles of responsible scholarly publishing.
2. Initial Editorial Screening
All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo initial editorial screening before being sent for external peer review.
At this stage, the Managing Editor and/or Scientific Editor assesses:
- The alignment of the research topic, objectives, methodology, and findings with the journal's aims and scope.
- The scientific relevance and significance of the research.
- Compliance of the manuscript type, structure, and content with the journal's requirements.
- The availability of required information on authorship, author contributions, funding, conflicts of interest, and the use of artificial intelligence.
- Compliance with research ethics requirements and the inclusion of relevant ethical declarations, where applicable.
- The accuracy and formatting of bibliographic references.
- Potential indications of violations of research integrity.
Particular attention is paid to the manuscript's alignment with the journal's aims and scope.
Manuscripts that lack a clearly established and scientifically substantiated connection to the journal's main subject areas may be rejected during initial editorial screening without being sent for external peer review.
If a manuscript requires correction of technical or formal deficiencies, the editorial office notifies the author accordingly.
Authors are given 10 calendar days to address such deficiencies. The editorial office may extend this period upon receipt of a justified request from the author. If no response is received, manuscript consideration may be discontinued, and the author will be notified.
Research Integrity Screening
Submitted manuscripts undergo textual similarity screening using specialized software.
The results of automated screening are evaluated by the editorial team, taking into account the nature and context of identified similarities, the appropriateness of citations, and potential indications of plagiarism.
A text similarity percentage alone is not sufficient grounds for determining a violation of research integrity.
Where potential violations are identified, the editorial team may request explanations from the authors, supplementary materials, or original research data. A decision to reject the manuscript is made after evaluating the relevant circumstances.
Posting a manuscript on a scientific preprint server is not, in itself, considered duplicate journal publication, provided that the journal's preprint policy is observed.
Manuscripts that meet the journal's essential editorial requirements are forwarded for independent external peer review.
3. Independent External Peer Review
Scientific manuscripts are evaluated by independent external experts with appropriate academic qualifications and research experience in the relevant field.
Original research articles and review articles are generally submitted to at least two independent reviewers.
Where necessary, the editorial team may invite additional reviewers, including specialists in statistical analysis, epidemiology, exposure and risk assessment, or other specialized research methods.
Reviewers are selected by the Editor-in-Chief or another authorized editor based on:
- The relevance of the reviewer's scientific expertise to the manuscript's subject area.
- Appropriate academic qualifications and research experience.
- Independence from the authors.
- The absence of financial, professional, personal, or other conflicts of interest.
- The ability to provide a well-substantiated review within the agreed timeframe.
Preference is given to reviewers who are not affiliated with the same institution as the authors and who have no direct academic dependency relationships with them.
Authors may suggest potential reviewers; however, the editorial team is not obliged to invite the suggested individuals and independently verifies their expertise and independence.
4. Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest
The journal operates a double-blind peer review process. Before a manuscript is sent to reviewers, the editorial team ensures that information directly identifying the authors is removed or concealed.
Reviewers are not provided with the authors' identifying personal information, although author identification may be possible through publicly available preprints or other openly accessible information.
Reviewers are required to maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts, accompanying materials, editorial correspondence, and the outcomes of their assessments.
Reviewers must not use unpublished materials, findings, data, or ideas obtained from manuscripts in their own research without appropriate permission.
Before accepting a review assignment, reviewers must disclose any circumstances that may affect their impartiality, including:
- Previous collaboration or recent co-authored publications with the authors.
- Affiliation with the same institution or participation in the same research project.
- Academic supervisory or subordinate relationships.
- Financial, personal, or other potential conflicts of interest.
Where a conflict of interest exists, the reviewer must decline the invitation or inform the editorial team so that the appropriateness of their participation can be determined.
If circumstances arise that call the independence of the review process into question, the editorial team appoints another reviewer.
5. Criteria for Scientific Evaluation of Manuscripts
During independent peer review, the following aspects of the manuscript are assessed:
1. Relevance and Scientific Novelty
Clarity of the scientific problem, justification of the study objectives, novelty of the research, and significance of the findings.
2. Methodological Quality
Appropriateness of the study design for addressing the research objectives, justification of the study sample, and validity of data collection and analysis methods.
3. Statistical Validity
Appropriateness of the statistical methods applied, completeness of results reporting, and adequacy of statistical interpretation.
4. Reliability of Findings
Consistency between research methods and reported findings, sufficiency of the supporting evidence, and the possibility of verifying the principal conclusions.
5. Scientific Discussion
Comparison of findings with current scientific research, critical interpretation of results, and appropriate discussion of study limitations.
6. Conclusions
Consistency of the conclusions with the study objectives, methods, and findings, and the absence of unsupported generalizations.
7. Bibliographic References
Relevance, reliability, and currency of cited sources, as well as the accuracy and appropriateness of citations.
8. Research Reporting and Ethical Compliance
Adherence to relevant EQUATOR Network reporting guidelines and the inclusion of required ethical declarations and information on funding, conflicts of interest, and data availability.
9. Quality of Presentation
Logical organization of the manuscript, clarity of academic writing, and appropriate presentation of tables, figures, and supplementary materials.
Reviewers are expected to provide constructive, well-reasoned, and professional comments aimed at ensuring an objective assessment and improving the scientific quality of the manuscript.
6. Reviewer Recommendations and Editorial Decisions
Following manuscript evaluation, each reviewer provides a written report explaining and justifying their recommendation.
The main reviewer recommendations are:
Accept
The manuscript meets the journal's scientific and editorial requirements and does not require substantial revision.
Minor Revision
The manuscript requires clarification, editorial corrections, or limited additions that do not alter the principal research findings.
Major Revision
Scientific or methodological deficiencies have been identified that may be addressed through substantial manuscript revision, additional analyses, or further justification of the findings.
Reject
The manuscript contains significant scientific, methodological, or ethical deficiencies that prevent it from being recommended for publication.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory in nature.
The final editorial decision is made by the Editor-in-Chief or another authorized editor, taking into consideration the peer review reports, scientific quality of the manuscript, its alignment with the journal's aims and scope, and the journal's editorial policies.
The editorial team may make a decision that differs from an individual reviewer's recommendation, provided that the decision is appropriately justified.
Authors are informed of the editorial decision and receive the relevant reviewer comments, with the confidentiality of reviewers' personal information maintained.
7. Handling Conflicting Reviewer Reports
Where reviewers' conclusions differ substantially, the handling editor conducts an additional assessment of the arguments presented.
Depending on the nature of the disagreement, the editorial team may:
- Invite a third independent reviewer.
- Request additional expert assessment of specific methodological or statistical issues.
- Seek clarification from the reviewers.
- Make a reasoned editorial decision based on all available evidence and assessments.
Disagreements between reviewers are not resolved automatically by counting positive or negative recommendations.
The final decision must be based on scientific arguments and the outcomes of an objective manuscript evaluation.
8. Manuscript Revision
Where a revision is requested, the editorial team forwards the reviewers' comments to the author and specifies a deadline for submitting the revised manuscript.
Authors are required to:
- Prepare a revised version of the manuscript.
- Provide a structured, point-by-point response to each reviewer comment.
- Explain the changes made and identify their locations in the revised manuscript.
- Provide a reasoned explanation for any disagreement with specific reviewer comments.
The revision deadline is determined according to the extent of the required changes and communicated to the author in the editorial decision letter.
Where necessary, authors may submit a justified request for an extension.
Upon receipt of the revised manuscript, the handling editor evaluates the extent to which the reviewers' comments have been addressed. If necessary, the manuscript is returned to the original reviewers or sent to additional reviewers for further assessment.
Submission of a revised manuscript does not guarantee acceptance for publication.
9. Peer Review of Manuscripts Submitted by Editorial Members and Employees of the Publisher
Manuscripts authored or co-authored by members of the Editorial Board, Editorial Council, Editorial Staff, or employees of the publishing institution undergo the standard procedures of initial editorial screening and independent external peer review.
Such manuscripts receive no preferential treatment or simplified evaluation procedures.
Individuals who are authors or co-authors of a manuscript, as well as editors with other conflicts of interest, must not participate in:
- Reviewer selection.
- Evaluation of peer review reports.
- Preparation of the editorial decision.
- Making the final publication decision.
Responsibility for handling such manuscripts is assigned to another authorized editor who has no conflict of interest.
If the conflict of interest involves the Editor-in-Chief, responsibility for handling the manuscript is transferred to an independent, authorized editor.
Publication decisions concerning manuscripts submitted by employees of the publishing institution are made without administrative or financial influence.
10. Use of Artificial Intelligence by Editors and Reviewers
Reviewers and editors are personally responsible for the objectivity, reliability, and content of their assessments.
Uploading confidential manuscripts, unpublished data, peer review reports, or editorial correspondence to external generative artificial intelligence systems is prohibited where appropriate confidentiality cannot be guaranteed and the necessary permission from the authors and the editorial team has not been obtained.
The use of artificial intelligence tools for supplementary tasks during peer review is permitted only in accordance with the journal's approved policy, subject to confidentiality requirements and disclosure to the editorial team of the nature of such use.
Artificial intelligence tools must not replace independent expert evaluation or assume responsibility for editorial decisions.
Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence.
11. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions
Authors have the right to submit a reasoned appeal against an editorial decision where potential procedural violations, conflicts of interest, or significant errors in manuscript evaluation are identified.
An appeal must be submitted in writing within 30 calendar days of receiving notification of the editorial decision.
The appeal must provide specific grounds for reconsideration and, where possible, supporting documentation.
The appeal is considered by the Editor-in-Chief or another authorized editor who was not involved in the decision being appealed and has no conflict of interest.
Independent experts may be consulted where necessary.
The editorial team informs the author of the outcome of the appeal within 30 calendar days of receipt or notifies the author if additional time is required.
Reconsideration does not guarantee that the previous editorial decision will be changed.
Complaints concerning potential violations of research integrity or publication ethics are handled in accordance with the journal's complaints procedure.
12. Peer Review Timelines
The editorial team aims to ensure the timely assessment of submitted manuscripts.
The estimated duration of external peer review is 2–4 weeks.
Actual review times may vary depending on the complexity of the research, the need to invite additional reviewers, the extent of required revisions, and other justified circumstances.
In the event of a substantial delay, the editorial team informs the author of the manuscript's review status.
The overall period from initial submission to the final editorial decision may exceed the estimated duration of an individual peer review stage.
The editorial team maintains records of manuscript submission dates, editorial decisions, and article acceptance dates. Aggregate indicators of editorial performance may be published in the Journal Statistics section.
13. Materials Not Subject to External Scientific Peer Review
Independent external scientific peer review applies to original research articles, scientific reviews, and other research-based manuscripts published as peer-reviewed scholarly articles.
Certain editorial materials may be exempt from external scientific peer review, including:
- Editorial statements and announcements.
- Informational notices issued by the editorial office.
- Notices of corrections to published articles.
- Expressions of Concern and retraction notices.
Such materials undergo the necessary editorial assessment, verification of factual accuracy, and checks for compliance with publication ethics.
The type of material and the editorial assessment procedure applied must be clearly identified to avoid presenting informational or editorial notices as peer-reviewed original research.
14. Transparency and Independence of Editorial Decisions
Peer review is conducted independently of research funding sources, authors' academic status, institutional affiliations, or countries of origin.
Payment of article processing charges does not influence reviewer selection, peer review outcomes, or final editorial decisions.
The administration of the publishing institution, sponsors, and other interested parties do not interfere with the independent scientific evaluation of manuscripts.
The editorial team ensures that the main stages of manuscript evaluation are appropriately documented in the journal's editorial management system and that relevant records are retained in accordance with established confidentiality requirements.
The peer review process is conducted in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics and Editorial Policy.
International Guidelines and Recommendations

