Policy on Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions of Published Articles
1. General Provisions
The scientific journal Environment & Health adheres to the principles of research integrity, transparency, and accountability for the reliability of published scientific information.
The editorial office ensures an appropriate response to significant errors, violations of publication ethics, and substantiated concerns regarding the reliability of research findings identified after article publication.
The purpose of this policy is to safeguard the integrity of the scholarly record, ensure timely communication with readers, and prevent the continued use of unreliable scientific findings.
Depending on the nature of the identified issue, the journal applies the following measures:
- Correction – amendment of errors that do not invalidate the principal research findings or conclusions.
- Expression of Concern – a formal notice indicating substantial and well-founded concerns about a publication when a final decision has not yet been reached or the available evidence is insufficient.
- Retraction – a formal notice indicating that the scientific findings or conclusions of a publication can no longer be considered reliable, or that other serious violations justify withdrawal of the article from the scholarly record.
This policy has been developed with reference to the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), and NISO RP-45-2024.
The purpose of retraction is to correct the scholarly record and safeguard its integrity, rather than to punish authors.
2. Corrections to Published Articles
A correction is published when errors or inaccuracies are identified after article publication that require formal clarification but do not undermine the reliability of the principal research findings and conclusions.
Grounds for issuing a correction may include:
- Errors in numerical data, tables, figures, or text that do not alter the principal conclusions of the study.
- Inaccuracies in the description of research methods or statistical analyses that require clarification.
- Errors in bibliographic information, funding disclosures, or conflict of interest statements.
- Justified changes or clarifications concerning authorship and author contributions.
- Other significant inaccuracies that can be resolved without retracting the article.
Depending on the origin of the error, the terms Erratum (correction of a publisher's error) and Corrigendum (correction of an author's error) may be used.
Minor technical errors that do not affect the content, interpretation, or bibliographic identification of an article may be corrected without a separate notice, provided that an appropriate record of changes is maintained.
Where a substantial correction is required, the editorial office publishes a separate notice specifying the nature of the error, the changes made, and the bibliographic details of the original article.
The corrected version of the article must indicate the date of the changes and include a link to the corresponding correction notice. Previous versions are retained to ensure transparency in the publication history.
3. Expressions of Concern
The editorial office may publish an Expression of Concern when substantial and well-founded concerns arise regarding a published article, but the available information is insufficient to reach a final decision on correction or retraction.
Grounds for issuing an Expression of Concern may include:
- Substantiated concerns regarding the reliability of research findings.
- Reports of possible fabrication, data falsification, or other serious violations.
- An ongoing investigation by a research institution or another competent authority whose findings are not yet available.
- Delays in or inability to complete an investigation where significant unresolved concerns remain.
- Other circumstances in which readers need to be alerted to the potential unreliability of a scholarly publication.
An Expression of Concern does not automatically establish research misconduct and is not a substitute for retraction.
The notice must:
- Clearly identify the article to which it relates.
- Explain the nature of the concerns identified.
- Specify which circumstances remain unverified.
- Inform readers of the status of the investigation, within the limits of information that the editorial office may lawfully and appropriately disclose.
- Include a link to the original publication.
Following completion of the investigation, the editorial office may publish a correction, retract the article, or issue a statement indicating that no grounds remain for further concern.
Where the concerns have been resolved, the editorial office publishes an appropriate notice and updates the article's status while preserving the history of previously published editorial notices.
4. Grounds for Retraction
Retraction is applied when established circumstances demonstrate substantial unreliability of scientific findings or other serious violations that cannot be adequately addressed through an ordinary correction.
An article may be retracted where there is sufficient evidence of:
- Data fabrication or falsification, including manipulation of research findings, images, or statistical results.
- Significant methodological or analytical errors that render the research findings or conclusions unreliable.
- Plagiarism or unauthorized use of other researchers' materials, where the nature of the violation justifies retraction.
- Duplicate or redundant publication without appropriate disclosure, permission, or scientific justification.
- Serious violations of research ethics, including requirements concerning ethical approval, informed consent, or protection of research participants.
- Manipulation of the peer review process that compromises the integrity of independent scientific evaluation.
- Guest or gift authorship, false authorship information, or other serious breaches of authorship responsibility that undermine the integrity of the scholarly record.
- Undisclosed significant conflicts of interest, where these have affected the interpretation of findings or the integrity of editorial assessment.
- Other serious violations of publication ethics that justify retraction.
Retraction may result from either deliberate misconduct or an honest error if the research findings are found to be unreliable.
Not every error, inaccuracy in authorship information, or instance of text reuse automatically warrants retraction. The editorial office assesses the nature and consequences of the issue and whether a less severe corrective measure would be appropriate.
Previous posting of a manuscript on a preprint server does not, in itself, constitute grounds for retraction, provided that it complies with the journal's Preprint Policy.
5. Initiation of an Investigation
The consideration of a correction, Expression of Concern, or retraction may be initiated by:
- Authors or co-authors of the publication.
- The Editor-in-Chief or other authorized editors.
- Peer reviewers.
- Readers and other researchers.
- Representatives of research institutions, organizations, or competent authorities.
A report should contain specific information about the alleged issue and, where possible, supporting evidence.
Editorial Office Contact: environ.and.health@health.gov.ua.
Anonymous reports may be considered if they contain sufficiently specific and verifiable information.
Submitting a report does not, in itself, constitute evidence of misconduct.
Investigations are conducted in accordance with the journal's policy for handling complaints concerning research integrity and publication ethics.
6. Investigation and Decision-Making Procedure
The consideration of post-publication corrections or retractions follows the stages outlined below.
Stage 1. Registration of the Report
The editorial office registers the report and conducts a preliminary assessment of its validity.
Stage 2. Appointment of the Responsible Person
The Editor-in-Chief appoints an authorized editor or a group of experts to investigate the circumstances.
Individuals with conflicts of interest must not participate in the investigation or decision-making process.
Stage 3. Examination of Evidence
The editorial office examines the publication, submitted evidence, and, where necessary, original research data, peer review reports, and other relevant documents.
Independent experts may be invited to participate in the investigation.
Where the matter concerns the conduct of the research or the determination of potential research misconduct, the editorial office may contact the authors' research institution or another competent authority.
Stage 4. Obtaining Explanations from Authors
The editorial office informs the authors of the nature of the identified concerns and provides them with an opportunity to submit written explanations and supporting materials.
Where possible, all authors of the article concerned are involved in the process.
Stage 5. Editorial Decision-Making
Following the investigation, the Editor-in-Chief or an independent, authorized editor decides whether to:
- Take no further action because insufficient grounds exist for making changes.
- Publish a correction.
- Publish an Expression of Concern.
- Retract the article.
- Continue the investigation where additional evidence is required.
The decision is documented, including its grounds, date, and the identity of the responsible person.
The final decision to retract an article rests with the Editor-in-Chief or another duly authorized, independent editor where the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest.
The publisher provides organizational, legal, and technical support for implementing the decision but must not exert improper administrative or financial influence over its scientific justification.
Authors' disagreement with the decision, or their failure to respond to editorial correspondence, does not prevent retraction where sufficient grounds have been established.
Investigations are conducted without unjustified delays. Where substantial risks to the integrity of the scholarly record exist, the editorial office may publish an Expression of Concern before the investigation has been completed.
7. Preparation and Publication of Editorial Notices
Where a decision is made to issue a correction, Expression of Concern, or retraction, the editorial office publishes a separate official notice.
The notice must include:
- A clearly identified document type: Correction, Expression of Concern, or Retraction.
- The title, authors, and complete bibliographic details of the original article.
- The DOI of the original publication.
- The justification for the editorial decision.
- The publication date of the notice.
- Information identifying the editor or other responsible party on whose behalf the notice is issued.
- Information linking the notice to the original publication.
The notice is made openly accessible on the journal's website and is included in the table of contents of the relevant issue or published as a separate editorial item with appropriate bibliographic identification.
A retraction notice must clearly explain why the findings or conclusions of the article can no longer be considered reliable or identify the other serious violations that justified retraction.
The editorial office must avoid vague statements that obscure the actual grounds for the decision.
At the same time, the notice must be objective, avoid unsubstantiated allegations, and refrain from disclosing confidential information without appropriate justification.
8. Preservation of Published Articles and Identification of Their Status
Following retraction, the article generally remains accessible in the journal's electronic archive.
A clear notice must be displayed on the article's HTML webpage, in its PDF, and in other available formats:
RETRACTED ARTICLE
The notice must indicate the date of retraction and provide a link to the corresponding official retraction notice.
The original publication and its retraction notice must contain reciprocal active links.
Where an Expression of Concern has been issued, the article's webpage must prominently display its status and provide a link to the corresponding editorial notice.
Where an article has been corrected, readers must have access to information describing the changes made, the date of correction, and the current version of the publication.
The unrecorded removal or replacement of published materials without appropriate notification is prohibited.
Complete removal of an article's full text from public access is permitted only under exceptional circumstances, particularly where substantial legal grounds exist, confidentiality has been compromised, or safety risks cannot be adequately addressed through other measures.
In such cases, the bibliographic record and an explanation of the reasons for removal should be retained wherever possible.
9. DOI, Crossref, and Bibliographic Metadata Updates
The editorial office ensures that post-publication changes are appropriately reflected in the journal's publishing system and international bibliographic services.
For significant editorial notices – Correction, Expression of Concern, and Retraction – registration of separate DOIs linked to the DOI of the original article is recommended.
The DOI of the original article is retained and must not be deleted.
The OJS administrator or designated editorial staff member is responsible for:
- Publishing the editorial notice with the appropriate bibliographic information.
- Registering the notice's DOI and depositing the necessary metadata with Crossref.
- Establishing a link between the original article and the editorial notice.
- Updating the article's status on its webpage.
- Verifying the accuracy of DOI links and the display of the publication's current status.
- Transmitting updated information to other bibliographic systems where supported by their technical capabilities.
Crossref mechanisms, including post-publication update metadata, are used to communicate information about corrections and retractions.
The use of Crossmark provides an additional means of indicating the current status of published articles but is not a mandatory prerequisite for registering such updates.
10. Appeals and Reconsideration
Authors have the right to submit a reasoned appeal against a decision to correct, issue an Expression of Concern for, or retract an article.
An appeal must be submitted in writing within 30 calendar days of notification of the editorial decision.
The appeal must provide specific grounds for reconsideration and, where possible, additional evidence or circumstances not previously considered.
The appeal is reviewed by an authorized editor who has no conflict of interest. Independent experts may be consulted where necessary.
The editorial office informs the appellant of the outcome within 30 calendar days or provides a justification for extending the review period.
Submitting an appeal does not, in itself, suspend a retraction decision where the need to protect the integrity of the scholarly record justifies its immediate implementation.
Where a significant error in an editorial decision is established, the journal publishes an appropriate notice and updates the article's status and metadata without concealing the previous publication history.
11. Confidentiality and Independence of Editorial Decisions
During investigations of potential violations, the editorial office ensures appropriate protection of personal data and confidential information.
All parties are given an opportunity to provide explanations in accordance with the established procedure.
Editors with personal, professional, or financial conflicts of interest must recuse themselves from the consideration of the matter concerned.
Decisions regarding corrections, Expressions of Concern, or retractions are independent of:
- The authors' country, institutional affiliation, or academic status.
- The presence or absence of financial support.
- Payment of article processing charges.
- Administrative influence from the publishing institution.
- Potential reputational consequences for the journal or individual participants in the publication process.
The editorial office is guided primarily by the reliability of scientific findings, the strength of the available evidence, and the need to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.
12. Final Provisions
Environment & Health ensures a responsible and transparent response to issues identified after the publication of scholarly articles.
This policy applies to post-publication issues identified in articles published by the journal, regardless of their publication year, subject to applicable legal requirements and relevant editorial procedures.
Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions are mechanisms for safeguarding the integrity of the scholarly record, not measures intended to punish authors.
This policy is periodically reviewed and updated in accordance with developments in international standards of scholarly publishing.
International Guidelines and Standards
- COPE – Retraction Guidelines, Version 3, August 2025.
- COPE – Expressions of Concern Guidelines.
- ICMJE – Corrections and Version Control.
- ICMJE – Scientific Misconduct, Expressions of Concern, and Retraction.
- NISO RP-45-2024 – Communication of Retractions, Removals, and Expressions of Concern.
- Crossref – Version Control, Corrections, and Retractions.

